The Modigliani-Miller Life Cycle Hypothesis
The Modigliani-Miller life cycle hypothesis (MMLCH) is a theory that suggests that a companys capital structure, or the combination of different types of funding that it relies on, is largely determined by the companys capital needs over its life cycle. This idea was developed in 1958 by economists Franco Modigliani and M.H. Miller, who argued that, under certain conditions, a businesss capital structure does not matter to its overall value. The conditions are: no taxes, no bankruptcy costs, and perfect capital markets, meaning investors can buy and sell securities at any time without incurring costs. Under these assumptions, Modigliani and Miller noted that a companys value is the same, regardless of its capital structure, or the mix of debt and equity that it chooses to finance its activities.
The MMLCH suggests that companies capital structure decisions should follow a life cycle which begins with the start-up phase, and progresses through the growth, maturity, and decline phases. In the start-up phase, a company is likely to rely mainly on equity funding, as debt will be too risky for the lender given the uncertain returns for investors. As the company enters the growth phase and begins generating positive cash flows, it will be able to attract additional financing by issuing debt, and may be better served by having a more balanced capital structure. This capital structure will allow the company to finance its growth while still paying shareholders a return on their investments, and will reduce the companys risk since a portion of its financing is secured.
The MMLCH further proposes that, as a company matures, its capital structure should become increasingly reliant on debt. This is because, as the companys cash flows and returns become more predictable, lenders will be willing to lend to it, providing the company with cheaper financing than that offered by equity. The company is also likely to generate enough cash to cover its interest expenses, thus reducing the risk of default. In the decline phase, the companys reliance on debt should decrease, as it is no longer able to generate enough cash to cover its interest expenses. The company may need to rely more on equity to finance its operations.
Although the Modigliani-Miller life cycle hypothesis is an important concept, its assumptions are unrealistic, and as such these predictions may not be applicable in practice. For example, companies may be subject to taxes, and therefore their capital structure decisions may need to factor taxes into account. Additionally, companies may incur bankruptcy costs which could override any theoretical gains from a particular capital structure choice. Furthermore, perfect capital markets do not exist in reality, meaning investors may incur costs when attempting to fund or divest of a company.
Despite the theoretical limitations of the Modigliani-Miller life cycle hypothesis, its insights remain useful as a guide to inform companies capital structure decisions. Companies may use the MMLCH to inform their decisions as to which sources of financing they should access and in what proportions at each stage of their life cycle. Therefore, while the predictions of the Modigliani-Miller life cycle hypothesis may not always be wholly applicable, they can still offer businesses an important framework to assist in the decision making process.
完